Sunday, May 28, 2017

21 - Chase Massner


Before I get started, I'd like to tell all of you to check out Crime Con, which is a true crime convention taking place in Indianapolis in June. I'm hoping to be there, along with Tyson and an army of other true crime hosts and experts, so I'm hoping it'll be a unique experience unlike any other. You can use the code "UNRESOLVED" to save 20% of your registration costs, and I hope to see you all there.

Also, listen through to the close to learn more about supporting the Unresolved Podcast on Patreon, and find out about some important changes coming up for the podcast in the near-future. I don't want to bore you with it right now, but it may impact how you access the podcast in the future, so stay tuned.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hello, welcome to the Unresolved Podcast. My name is Micheal Whelan, and this episode is going to discuss the disappearance of Georgia native Chase Massner.

As you heard in the intro, this is a story that has been covered by local Georgia news outlets and even true crime host Nancy Grace herself, but remains under-discussed at-large.

This episode is going to try and detail the life of Chase Massner up until his disappearance, including the cast of characters that surrounded him in his final known days. And later in the episode, I'll also feature a discussion I had not too long ago with Nancy Grace herself, so stay tuned for that.

This is the story of Chase Massner.


Chase Tyler Massner was born on September 4th, 1987, to his father Corbin Massner and his mother Stephanie Cadena. Both parents were very young, just a hair above twenty years old, so it's not a huge shock to me that the two didn't grow old together.

Records for Chase's early life are few and far in-between, the only thing being an arrest for marijuana possession on August 22nd, 2005. Chase was just eighteen, and the mugshot of him is a far-cry from the man he would later become. The charge didn't stick, though, or else Chase wouldn't have been able to accomplish one of his life goals: enlisting in the United States Army.

Chase Massner's mugshot from 2005

In the latter half of the 2000s, Chase would join the US military, and he would later get sent halfway across the world to serve a year in Iraq.


When Chase returned, he was suffering from the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder. At least, that's what his wife, Amanda, would later state.

Amanda and Chase would date and get married during this time period, the time around Chase's return from Iraq. He would be discharged from the Army, presumably due to cutbacks.

Christin Amanda Chattom, who was called Amanda by everyone in her life, would become Amanda Massner. The couple's first child, a beautiful daughter named Sydney, would be born shortly thereafter.

I wish I could say that things would come together for this young couple, who presumably didn't want to repeat the mistakes of Chase's parents. Unfortunately, their situation would become complicated over the next few years, creating a situation that would make any future investigation a nightmare.

Chase with his mother, Stephanie Cadena

It seems that, throughout his lifetime, Chase had remained close to his family.

His mother, Stephanie Cadena, has worked with a family-owned auto repair company for years now, and always had a close relationship with her son. Apparently, whenever Chase had trouble with Amanda, he would go to his mother's to stay the night or to simply talk and discuss his issues. The two seemed to have the type of relationship that any mother and son should have.

However, Chase's relationship with his dad is a definite mystery to me. Corbin Massner, Chase's father, as an entity that I consider a wildcard to the investigation.

He was apparently a truck driver, who in the months before Chase's disappearance, had moved in with Chase's family. He had apparently been let go from his job, for a reason I'll discuss later.
This would only compound a financial situation that was getting tricky for Chase and his wife Amanda to manage.

You see, after Chase had been discharged from the military, he would struggle to make ends meet. He would work random job, but struggled to stay employed to the point of providing for his family. Then, when Amanda became pregnant with their second child, that struggle worsened.

He took a job as the night manager of a nearby Quik Trip, located off of Bells Ferry Road in Kennesaw, Georgia. This meant that he would have to work the overnight shift, but would be able to at least keep a roof over his family's head for the time being.

This Quik Trip was about thirteen miles away from the Massner family home, located on Serenoa Drive in Canton, Georgia. However, it was just over a mile away from the home of Chase's friend, Brad Clement, who will come into play momentarily.

When one looks at pictures of Chase's home, located up in Canton, Georgia, they wonder how a family of four - five, if you include Chase's father, Corbin - was able to live in it off of just a single hourly wage. Word has been that the couple got a good deal on it, but as someone who's worked hourly jobs for the better part of the last decade, I truly wonder how far that extends.

Because of this financial instability, things had been growing tense between Chase and Amanda. Now with two kids on their hands, and Chase's schedule completely flipped on its head, things seemed poised to snap for the young couple struggling to make ends meet.

Chase and Amanda as a young couple

In March of 2014, the struggles between Chase and Amanda continued. Their arguments were becoming more and more frequent, and apparently Chase would use his mother, Stephanie Cadena, as an outlet of sorts to help mediate the issue.

At times, this would just be Stephanie called to help out with an issue or two. However, at others, it would mean Chase staying at her house for a night or two, to simply let the couple have some space and work out their differences at a later date.

Amanda called Stephanie, and apparently told her about the issues the couple had been having lately. Most of it stemmed from their financial woes, but there was a lot of frustration and tension there. According to both Stephanie and Amanda, it wasn't anything insurmountable, but it was leading the couple to a place that they didn't want to be. So it was decided that Chase would spend a few nights at his mom's house, to let cooler heads prevail.

On Wednesday, March 26th, Amanda picked up Chase from his mother, Stephanie's home. The kids were in the backseat, waiting to see their Dad once again. They all said their goodbyes, Stephanie having no idea at the time that it would be the last time she'd see her son.

This is where the story begins to enter the murky territory of "he said/she said." From this point forward, all we have to go on is the testimony of the band of characters around Chase Massner: namely, his wife, and the friend I mentioned just a moment ago, Brad Clements.

On the way home from Chase's mother's home, apparently, the arguments struck up once again. It was apparently so bad that the couple didn't even make it home together; some have rumored that Amanda kicked Chase out of the car, but all we know is that Chase would be dropped off just a few miles way, at the Quik Trip location he worked at off of Bells Ferry Road.

Seeing as how the couple lived over ten miles away, north in Canton, it goes to reason that the couple had been in the car for only a few minutes before the argument got so bad that they couldn't even make it home together.

Brad Clement

James Bradshaw Clement, most commonly referred to by his middle name Brad, was a friend of Chase's. I can't tell you how the two became friends - whether they knew each other before Chase's deployment to Iraq or not - but they were roughly the same age, and both of them grew up in the Atlanta, Georgia area. They had apparently only hung out together a few times, so I'm curious as to how they became acquainted.

Brad lived in Kennesaw, Georgia, which is a small town about half an hour to the north of Atlanta... on a good day. I live not too far from this area, so I can just tell you that the Atlanta area itself is very, very busy, but the surrounding areas are surprisingly beautiful. You can travel just a few miles outside of Atlanta and hit some scenic patches of forest. Kennesaw is no exception, with a beautiful downtown and a population hovering at around 30,000.

Brad worked with computers for a living, which he would fix up in his house. Records show that he was also working for T-Mobile at around this time period, but without speaking to him, I can't verify that.

Nonetheless, Brad was a pretty self-made man. He owned his own home - a rather nice one, at the end of a cul-de-sac on Farmbrook Trail. He seemed like a regular guy - still does, despite the maelstrom that has become his life in the years since.

After Amanda dropped Chase off at the Quik Trip he worked at, which was just over a mile away from Brad's home, he apparently went to pick up his buddy.

For the rest of the evening, these two friends apparently spent a good chunk of their time talking. Brad remembers that Chase told him all about the issues him and Amanda were having, and that the two just hung around to shoot the breeze.

And, according to Brad, he also tried to play mediator for a bit. For a while after Chase's future disappearance, text messages between him and Amanda on the night in-question would become analyzed by investigators, but apparently most of them were sent by Brad himself. He was texting Amanda through Chase's phone, trying to help the two of them bridge the gap.

In his texts to Amanda, he apparently had begun floating the idea of a barbecue. You see, Brad was having roofers working on his house throughout this time period, in March of 2014, and he was planning to host a barbecue for them the next night. He wanted Chase to invite Amanda and their kids, and hopefully help calm things down with some burgers and hot dogs. Or whatever it was they were cooking, maybe I'm just hungry and daydreaming.

The next morning, on Thursday the 27th of March, Brad woke up, with the intention of delivering a computer to a client's home. He had been working on it for a bit, and had been finishing it up the previous night, as he spoke to Chase. He told Chase to hang out at his house for a bit, just to sleep in and catch a bit of a break.

This is where one of the most peculiar aspects of the story come into play. When Brad left to deliver the computer, he took Chase's cell phone with him.

Chase's cell phone case was also his wallet, so this meant that Brad was taking away Chase's lifeline, essentially. However, he states that he was doing this in an effort to keep Chase at his home; after all, without his cell phone or his wallet, how would Chase get anywhere?

Needless to say, the story continues to get muddled after this.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

One of the biggest hurdles facing this story is whether or not Brad Clements was telling the truth. Because, as sad as it is to say, all we know about Chase's final hours are based off of his testimony.

He recalls the day that Chase vanished as a rather mundane one. He had taken Chase's cell phone with him, to prevent Chase from leaving his house, and ran some errands with it in his possession. He delivered his computer, came back home, and apparently Chase was still there. But then he states that he left again that afternoon to pick up groceries for the barbecue, and around this time was when Chase disappeared.

People have questioned whether Brad was telling the truth about all of that. Any of that, rather.
In a recent interview on Nancy Grace's podcast, Brad tells of how him and Chase smoked some weed and drank some alcohol on the night in-question, but doesn't go into much detail. He also states that when he picked up Chase, he found the Army veteran looking for "roxy" pills: also known as roxicodone, an opiate pain reliever that has become popular over the last few years.

You'd think that this would be a huge clue for the investigation. If someone is ever trying to score drugs, all they need is a contact to get the drugs, and the money to purchase them.

Brad pleads ignorance when it comes to that kind of substance, stating that he had taken them in the past after a car accident and disliked them, but didn't know where to get any. However, he also claims to have given Chase $60 before his disappearance, which leads me to think that Chase might have been looking for a substance for any reason at all: whether it be his relationship issues, his claimed PTSD, or whatever.

This is something that a lot of media outlets seem to have overlooked. Brad, while perhaps being the "wild card" of the entire story, is the only person we have that can vouch for the final 24 hours of Chase's life, and most of what he says is brushed off to the side as people rush to suspicions about him, personally.


As I said just a moment ago, during this time period, Brad was having work done to his house. Primarily, having his roof replaced by a small operation known as Ducks Roofing.

Brandon Duck, the owner and operator of Ducks Roofing, was at Brad's house for a large chunk of that day, along with a couple of his employees.

When Brad returned from running errands, the roofers remember seeing him and interacting with him. They had also seen him that morning, when they first showed up. They were also planning on staying, as Brad had invited them for a cook-out.

Brad returned from the grocery store, and began preparing for the barbecue. He claims that, in the process of getting the grill going, that he accidentally caught a section of his backyard on fire. He apparently had to go through quite an ordeal putting it out, and when he came back inside to talk to Chase about it, his friend was allegedly gone.

This is when the following phone call takes place.

This voicemail establishes just a couple of things.

First off, this means that Chase had disappeared or gone missing in the middle of the day. You'd think that someone would have seen him leaving, since Brad's house was at the end of a cul-de-sac and it would have taken Chase a good walk to get out of the neighborhood.

However, another thing it establishes is that Brad's testimony was getting shaky. You see, those roofers that were working on his house? Brandon Duck, who had at least two coworkers with him? None of them remember seeing Chase at all; not in the morning, not in the afternoon, and definitely not leaving Brad Clement's home.

Brandon Duck's FB post from days after Chase's disappearance

I don't want to throw any stones at Brad Clement; for all I know, he's as innocent as anyone in this story, but things like that don't do him any favors. He would later state that hearing that Chase had left from his roofers was just a simple miscommunication, but one has to wonder how such a thing happens. How would someone tell you a house-guest had left when they had no idea they were there in the first place? It just boggles the mind.

Needless to say, though, the search was beginning for Chase Massner.

The last known photo taken of Chase Massner

Apparently, before Brad made his call to Chase's phone, word had already spread to Chase's family.
I couldn't tell you how the game of telephone worked, but at this point, Brad was under the assumption that Amanda had picked up Chase from his home while he was in the backyard.

However, it was clear that Chase's family had begun discussing Chase's extended absence just a tad beforehand.

That was a call from Stephanie Cadena, Chase's mother, placed roughly fifteen minutes before Brad called Chase. In it, she's already worrying about Chase's whereabouts, after learning that he had never made it home with Amanda the prior evening.

They began to work their way through the motions: finding out where Chase had last been, and working their way from there. Amanda and Stephanie got in touch with Brad, who informed them that Chase had slipped out that afternoon, apparently being spotted by the roofers working on his home... which we now know didn't happen. However, they began to get in-touch with Chase's other friends and associates, but had no such luck in finding him.

No one in Brad's neighborhood recalls seeing Chase that afternoon. You can't really blame them on that. Would you be aware of someone walking around your neighborhood in the approximate time-frame of 1:00 to 3:00 in the afternoon? I wouldn't. But the odds of NO ONE spotting him has to be pretty low, I wager.

Nonetheless, Chase had disappeared without a trace. His story was soon called in to the police, but unfortunately, they began investigating him as a voluntary departure. Meaning, of course, that they believe he disappeared willingly.

Brad Clement's home, where Chase was last seen

One of the many aspects of the case that has continued to haunt it, now three-plus years later, is the fact that it was first investigated by Chase's hometown Cherokee County police force.

As I stated before, he lived in Canton, Georgia, with his wife, Amanda, his two children, and now his father, Corbin.

Therefore, it fell upon Cherokee County police to investigate his absence. But, when things like this happen, things fall in between-the-gaps. I covered this type of occurrence back in the Long Island Serial Killer episodes, when some of the girls - namely Shannan Gilbert - disappeared in one area, but had their cases handled by their hometown police force, who often lived miles away.

Chase was last seen in Kennesaw, Georgia, which is located in Cobb County. Because of the overlap, this saw the case hit some hurdles from the very get-go. The most insurmountable disadvantage Chase's family saw was when police investigated Chase's disappearance as a voluntary absence. This meant, basically, that they thought he had run away.

On Nancy Grace's podcast episodes featuring an interview with Brad Clement, he states that Chase had stated - on more than one occasion - that he was going to run away and live in the woods.

Obviously, I can't say that this was a common expression of his. I can't find anyone else that vouches for these statements, but police must have found some hint of truth in them, because they didn't think that there was anything nefarious about Chase's disappearance.

But as the hours turned into days, the belief that he had simply gone willing into the night began to be stretched thin.

He supposedly had his debit card and cell phone with him, but the last that his debit card was used was the night before his disappearance: Wednesday, March 26th. This was also the night that he had gone over to Brad's home. It was just for a couple of dollars, I believe, meaning that it could have been for anything: soda, a beer, a snack, chap stick, etc.

The last time that Chase's phone would be used was the next day, March 27th. This was the day he disappeared. He had made a call the night before, on Wednesday, at roughly 10:30 in the evening, but I couldn't tell you to who that call was made.

You see, the unfortunate thing is that - just like Chase - we have no idea what happened to his cell phone. Some statements would have you believe that Brad was holding onto it all day long, but there's just no evidence to support that. And some statements have perhaps been taking out-of-context to imply that Amanda has had it, but we do know that Chase had upgraded his phone a month or so before his absence... meaning that Amanda may have simply had Chase's old phone, which would likely still have old text messages, photos, contacts, etc.

However, none of this would help police. Even when they began to investigate Chase's case more urgently - and it was finally handed back to the Cobb County police squad, whose jurisdiction was the area where Chase actually disappeared - all trace of him was gone in the wind.


Brad Clement has not been alone in facing backlash regarding statements made after Chase's disappearance. Amanda Massner, Chase's own wife, has also become one of the internet's prime suspects, because of conflicting statements she made about the last night she was with Chase, Wednesday, March 26th.

In the days after her husband's disappearance, Amanda supposedly gave conflicting statements about where, exactly, she had dropped him off. Stephanie Cadena, Chase's mother, recalls hearing from Amanda that she had dropped him off at the Quik Trip he worked at. However, she also recalls hearing in another instance how Amanda had dropped him off directly at Brad's home.

Here's a phone call Amanda was making to someone, in which she mentions how scrutinized she would become in the weeks and months after Chase's disappearance.

Amanda would also face scrutiny from Brad Clements himself, of all people.

In his recent interview with Nancy Grace, Brad alleges that Amanda came to him the day after Chase's disappearance, not only looking for weed, but also hitting on him. He says without explicitly saying that she was flirting with him, as if she was mad at Chase for running away, and wanted to get back at him in some way. Brad also alleges that Amanda's mother was growing weed, and that Amanda was somehow involved in that operation, but gives no real details.

Here's Amanda, when questioned by a veteran's group who would launch a search for Chase.

A few things to unpack from that.

First of all, it's hard to differentiate whether or not she's talking about Chase having an issue with marijuana or heroin at the end there. Before this audio, I was honestly unaware that Chase had struggled with any hard narcotics in the past. When you read about him, it's generally very positive stuff; when it comes to missing persons reports, you don't often hear about the negatives of their life. Which sucks, in my opinion, because it's often those negatives that can help create leads to find out what happened to them.

Case-in-point: if Chase had had issues in the past with heroin, and was out looking for an opioid, it makes sense to think that he might have gotten ahold of some. But I'll get into that later.

However, another piece from that audio is at the very beginning, when Amanda mentions that she had closed off from everyone.

In the weeks after Chase's disappearance, Amanda was very much in front of the case, pleading with everything and everyone to help bring about some results. However, over time, she has become more withdrawn, eventually leaving Georgia and refusing to speak to anyone.

This is mainly because of a man named Paul Libri.

Paul Libri was a private investigator, operating out of Georgia, who became embedded in the search to find Chase Massner in 2014. He endeared himself to Amanda Massner, and I'm assuming was eventually hired by the mother of two to find her missing husband.

Here's a conversation between the two, in which Amanda tells Libri her thoughts about the case, about Brad Clement, and what she wants done to find her husband.

However, unbeknownst to Amanda, Paul Libri was facing charges of impersonating a police officer in another investigation, which would eventually land him in prison with a conviction.

He had apparently pretended to be a cop during the investigation of a missing teenage girl in Palmetto, Georgia. In 2015, he was found guilty of two charges of impersonating a police officer, and one charge each of both identity fraud and obstruction of justice - charges spanning across multiple occasions where he had pretended to be a cop.

It was after this - after putting so much faith and information in the hands of a private investigator - that Amanda began to shut herself off from the outside world. She hasn't spoken to the media in quite some time: not about Chase, his disappearance, or anything involving the two. She left Georgia with her daughters and moved to Iowa, under odd circumstances.


If I may, I'll turn the focus back on Brad Clement for a bit.

In the weeks after Chase Massner's disappearance, Brad was not suspected of any wrongdoing. Police didn't believe that he had anything to do with Chase being missing... after all, they were originally investigating him as a voluntary departure.

Brad was originally asked to take a polygraph by the police, but refused. He stated that his nerves would have been too messed up to take one; and honestly, I can't blame him. After doing a good amount of research on polygraphs, I don't believe that they're good indicators of truth whatsoever. Anyone with a brain can try and figure out how to fake one, which I talked about a bit in the Misty Copsey episodes of this podcast. Also, they don't measure truth whatsoever, just someone's stress level regarding a question; the verbiage of which can be what triggers a response, not the question itself.

For example, if I were to ask you "did you kill this person?" You might have a strong response no matter whether you did or not. I can't blame Brad for not wanting to subject himself to that and implicate himself based on a heartbeat.

However, word began to reach police that Brad, who had been having  work done on his home, had had a dumpster in front of his house. Several people, many of Chase's friends and family, wanted police to investigate this.

Police would eventually get around to it, some time after Chase had already gone missing. However, they would later discover that the dumpster they had examined - at a local landfill - had been the wrong one. By the time they recognized their mistake, it was too costly to remedy. The dumpster had already been dumped into a local landfill, and they've openly admitted to Chase's family that the cost of going back to search the area where the dumpster was disposed of would be upwards of seven digits.

Sadly, even if this was more than just a hunch, it would be a very costly endeavor. And the chances of them finding something, after more than three years, would be slim to none to begin with.

But that was just another mistake in a long list of them that would go on to damage the integrity of the investigation.

Brad Clement was never an official suspect by police, even though the story of this mysterious dumpster and his ever-changing alibi have made him a prime suspect in the public eye. He has faced severe public backlash in the years since, which even drove him out of his home and out of the area he grew up in. He moved out of his home just months after Chase disappeared, and his only public sighting was during his interview with Nancy Grace just a month or so ago.

Brad Clement, speaking to Nancy Grace in early 2017

I'll get into some theories of mine in just a moment, but I had the opportunity to speak to famous personality Nancy Grace not too long ago. I know that she's a very divisive figure when it comes to true crime, but I was pleasantly surprised that she took the time to speak to me about Chase Massner, which is a story she has done a lot to promote.

Also, I'll apologize for some of the audio quality. After my digital recording got corrupted, I had to utilize my backup recorder's version of the conversation. It was my first interview, so I hope you all cut me some slack.

But here you go, my conversation with Nancy Grace.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm really grateful to Nancy for speaking to me. At the time, I wasn't too well-versed on some of the issues, but she really helped clarify them for me and explained her thoughts on the matter. So, if you're listening, Nancy, thank you. I know many have disagreements on how she broaches certain stories, but she was nothing but nice to me.

There were a few things, however, that I disagree with her about. Namely, of course, the issue of drugs and mental illnesses, which I've briefly touched on in this episode.

It seems to me that the topic of drugs haven't really been brought up at all in relation to Chase's disappearance. He was arrested for the possession of marijuana as a baby-faced eighteen-year old, and according to the conversation we listened to between Amanda and another woman, Chase may have had issues with heroin in the past.

Then, of course, we have Brad saying that Chase was looking for "roxies," aka roxicodone, an opioid pain reliever. While this may just be a byproduct of Brad deflecting, it's a worthy lead to consider, that I haven't seen a lot of people talk about.

During the research for this episode, I happened to stumble upon a few articles talking about heroin use in Georgia, most printed at around the time period that Chase disappeared.

Now, I'm not saying that I believe Chase did heroin. For all I know, he never touched the stuff. So I just want to pre-empt the discussion by saying that. However, considering that we've heard audio of his wife discussing the fact that he may have had a problem with narcotics in the past, and that the last known person Chase spoke to said he was looking for opioids, I think it's at least worthy of a discussion.

With that said, I think it's relevant to note that between 2013 and 2014, the amount of people killed due to  drug overdoses increased by over 10%. That's not nothing. In 2010, the state faced just three deaths caused by heroin overdoses. In 2013, that number had risen to 32. Then, in 2014, that number had nearly doubled from the year prior, to 59 deaths caused by heroin in the state of Georgia.

The following is from a WSB-TV Atlanta news clip.

That was a heart-breaking story, which I find very similar to that of Chase Massner's. Davis Owen was a promising young man with the entire world in front of him.

It's also note-worthy that this story was presented by WSB-TV less than a week before Chase Massner's disappearance, and came at around the time a batch of tainted heroin had hit the area of Atlanta.

Davis Owen attended school at Kennesaw State University, not even five minutes away from the Quik Trip that Chase worked at; just three or so miles away from where Brad Clement lived.

Here's a phone conversation between Brad Clement and Amanda Massner, on April 16th of 2014, just a few weeks after Chase had disappeared. It's also worth noting that this conversation took place at 2:00 in the morning, which explains why Amanda sounds so tired.

To me, it sounds like Brad is implying that Chase might have searched out a local drug dealer - or someone that he had associated with drugs in the past. It seems like in the beginning, Brad is hinting at something other than weed, which Amanda casually states. Maybe that's just me reading too much into it, after listening to that recording dozens of times, but I find this conversation very intriguing.

Like I said earlier in the episode, I don't want to believe that Chase Massner was the victim of a heroin overdose. But, unfortunately, the alternatives don't sound much more plausible. I don't believe that someone would have tried to abduct Chase - an Army veteran who was still in great shape - and I also don't believe that he would have willingly ran away and left his family behind.

The only other plausible alternative, I feel, is that Chase was suffering from severe mental health issues. He had been suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, after his tour in Iraq, which we know after hearing his wife, Amanda, say so in an audio clip. I've also seen reports that Chase may have been suffering from the beginning stages of bipolar disorder, but that seems more like internet speculation than anything. He would be at the right age for a mental instability to start manifesting itself, but we have no definitive proof that that's what was happening.

Brad Clement said in an offhand remark that Chase had talked about running off and living in the woods. Who knows? Maybe he did. Maybe he's been living in the Georgia woods for years, surviving and scavenging. That's what I'd like to think happened to Chase Massner.


In the years since Chase Massner disappeared, many of the lives he touched have struggled to move on.

Brad Clement, the friend who was the last known person to see Chase, has struggled. He gave up his big house in Kennesaw, Georgia, and has struggled to remain employed. He states that the scrutiny brought upon him, following the disappearance of his friend, is just too much. He hopes that his recent interview with Nancy Grace will help clear his name.

Amanda Massner, Chase's wife, moved out of Georgia with the couple's two kids roughly a year after Chase went missing. She also faced her fair amount of scrutiny, and decided that it wasn't a good environment for their two children to grow up in. She moved to the Burlington region of Iowa, which not coincidentally, is where Chase's father, Corbin, lives.

Corbin Massner, who had been living with the couple in the months before Chase's disappearance, is an enigma to me. I can see that he has a bit of a checkered past when it comes to the law - which I won't go into detail about here - and was let go from his job in 2013 because of it. That's why he was living with his son's family during this time period.

Corbin Massner

It seems like Amanda chose to remain close to Corbin, her children's grandfather, and followed him back to Iowa.

Stephanie Cadena, Chase's mother, still lives in Georgia, and has remained the most vocal proponent of finding Chase over the past few years.


Answers about Chase Massner have been few and far in-between. He received a strong show of support from the online community in the first year or so after his disappearance, but bickering and infighting between the groups led to much of the conversations getting blocked or deleted. I've been trying to speak to the largest Facebook community in search of people that know Chase, but have gotten nowhere.

A short while after Chase went missing, a mysterious comment by his father Corbin inspired a bit of controversy. He told members of the online community to "stop posting about Chase," and implied that he'd never be found. This comment, while very odd and off-putting, has resulted in no new information coming to light.

Several groups, including some veteran's groups and Missing in America, have conducted searches in the area around Cobb and Cherokee County to try and track down Chase. Unfortunately, after three years, they have yet to find anything concrete.

Chase Massner stood six-foot-two, and weighed about one-hundred-and-seventy-five pounds at the time of his disappearance. He was a physically attractive young man, with dark hair and multiple tattoos. He had tattoos on his chest, including two roses, his last name "Massner" scrawled along the top of his back, the phrase "Never Depart 02-07-2010" on his right forearm, and other miscellaneous tattoos. He was last seen wearing a red Quik Trip sweatshirt and khaki pants.

If any of these sound familiar, please get in touch with the Cobb County Police Department at 770-499-3945. The reward for information is now $5000, and this case has been forwarded to the cold case unit.

The story of Chase Massner is still unresolved.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If you're interested in following along with the podcast on social media, and staying privy to all of the changes coming ahead, you can find us at: twitter.com/UnresolvedPod, facebook.com/theunresolvedpodcast, or you can even follow along at the podcast's website, theunresolvedpodcast.com. There, you can find links to the aforementioned sites, transcripts for each episode, articles and sources I utilize for research, and any pertinent information that you may need.

If you'd like to stay in touch in other ways, you can reach me at theunresolvedpodcast@gmail.com or 831-200-3550, which is available for your calls and texts.

If you'd like to help the podcast continue to evolve, you can do so at Patreon.com/unresolvedpod. There, you can become a patron, and get access to a bevy of perks, such as the rough cut of each episode as soon as its recorded, unedited interviews, audio clips and extras we cook up, and even vote for an upcoming episode. Also, soon it will be the only place to get episodes without any advertisements. It's because of these Patreon supporters that I was recently able to upgrade some recording equipment, which is why this episode sounds noticeably improved from the last.

The next goal we're aiming for is to have regular episodes every two weeks. You can help us reach that goal by supporting the podcast on Patreon.

Speaking of, I'd like to thank the following people for becoming patrons since the last episode: Nathan, Tobias, Clem, Vivian, and Lauren. The five of you have joined the ranks of my favorite people, so thank you.

As always, I'd like to throw a debt of gratitude towards Tyson Nordgren, who continues to weave his musical magic on each episode. I say this all of the time, but I owe him so much for holding my hand throughout the recording and editing process, and the work he does for the podcast is tremendous. Thanks, Tyson!

Lastly, of course, I have to say thank you to Nancy Grace, who was kind enough to speak to me about the case of Chase Massner. I can only hope to speak to her again in the future, and hopefully with some semblance of a happy ending involved.

And, before I leave, I'd like to recommend that you all check your podcast app and search for any other feeds of the podcast. I'm going to be switching over soon, so whether you listen on iTunes, Stitcher, or some other app, just check and make sure that if there are two Unresolved Podcast feeds, you're subscribed to both. One is going to stop updating in the near-future, and I just want to make sure that you don't miss out on any episodes.

I know I say this all of the time, but I hope to not have any more long gaps between episodes. Things have finally begun to normalize, and the more supporters the podcast gets means the more time I can dedicate to it. So continue to spread the word, whether it be through a share on social media, a review on iTunes or Stitcher, or a pledge on Patreon. Every little bit helps.

Thanks for listening, everyone. Until next time, stay safe.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Links

CrimeOnline - "Where is Chase Massner? Veteran disappears, family frantic for answers."

Charley Project - Chase Tyler Massner

NBC News - "Missing in America: Chase Massner"

Websleuths - "GA - Chase Massner, 26, Kennesaw, 27 March 2014"

CrimeOnline - "Chase Massner: Reward money increases to $10K as battle buddies vow to never give up until missing veteran is found"

Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - Podcast Directory

CBS 46 Atlanta - "Mother continues search for son and veteran, missing for 6 month"

CBS 46 Atlanta - "Cold case on veteran's disappearance re-opened by Nancy Grace"

WSB-TV 2 Atlanta - "Family prays for safe return of missing Iraq War vet"

WBTV.com - "Family holds vigil for veteran, father who went missing 3 years ago"

Kennesaw 11 Alive - "Chase Massner search ends; turns up area of 'high interest'"

Arrests.org - Chase Massner

13 WMAZ - "Search continues for missing war veteran"

Douglasville Patch - "Man Convicted of Impersonating Officer During Missing Teen Search"

WSB-TV 2 Atlanta - "Mother on mission to find man who sold deadly drugs to son"

Online Athens - "Heroin-related deaths increasing in Georgia"

CBS 46 Atlanta - "Heroin overdose deaths skyrocket in Georgia, authorities warn against dangers"

Monday, April 10, 2017

20 - The Family Murders (Part Two: The Family)


In the years since pulling Roger James from the Torrens River back in 1972, Bevan Spencer von Einem had lived a relatively mundane life... at least, from the outside looking in.

He was now an accountant for a supplies company, edging closer to forty years old, and he lived with his mother in a small house in northeastern Adelaide.

However, it turns out, that on the side of his everyday "good ol boy" demeanor who endeared himself to his mother's older friends and played it nice at work, he was a sexual sadist that liked to abduct, drug, sexually assault, and occasionally murder young men between the ages of thirteen and twenty-five.

When one looked at Bevan von Einem, they didn't see a monster. Very few violent offenders actually look like a monster. Most people saw a man who wasn't terrible-looking, despite having a very particular look: his chin was very large, and his hair had been prematurely graying since he was sixteen years old. He needed to frequent a hairdresser  - a friend of his named Denis St. Denis - at least once a month in order to bring it back to the darkened shade of his youth. One word I've seen used to describe Bevan Spencer von Einem is: soft. I think that's a pretty apt description of him, because he looks exactly like what you'd imagine an accountant from the 1980s to look like.


Bevan von Einem apparently suffered from insomnia and other sleep issues, which had forced him to resort to late night, alcohol-fueled drives around Adelaide to comfort himself. Later, it resulted in him having prescriptions to multiple sleep agents, such as Mandrax and Rohypnol. This is what put him on the map of police, now investigating the high-profile murder of Richard Kelvin.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hello, welcome to the Unresolved Podcast. I am your host, Micheal Whelan, and this episode is part two of my take on the Family Murders. If you haven't listened to part one, I highly encourage you do that, because this episode is a direct continuation of that story, so you might be a bit lost.

Before I officially begin the episode, I have to make a mention of something. In the last episode, I prefaced the story with a pre-apology, warning anyone that my terminology when it came to certain things might not be up-to-snuff. Throughout the episode, I utilized words such as "transexual" and "homosexual," both of which were - I later discovered - unacceptable. I apologize to anyone that may have been offended by the usage of those words, and I promise that that is a mistake I will remedy in the future. In an episode full of dark and grisly acts, I honestly didn't concern myself with looking up the proper terminology, and that is unacceptable on my part. For that, I am sorry. I can only hope that it didn't detract from the story itself, which is one that needs to be told.

I also apologize, in that I'm still recovering from a really bad case of allergies. I recently made the move from the west coast to Georgia, and it turns out that I'm allergic to the South. Who knew? Anyhow, if my voice sounds a bit scratchy, that's why.

To recap the last episode: in 1979, the body of 16-year old Alan Barnes was found, having been drugged and sexually assaulted by his killer before being dumped along the bank of the South Para Reservoir. Within months, police discovered another body - that of 25-year old Neil Muir, a known vagrant and drug user - which was mutilated, almost beyond recognition. He, too, had been raped, just like Barnes. They thought they had found their suspect - Dr. Peter Millhouse - but that lead turned out to be a dead-end, and he was eventually acquitted of all charges.

The murders seemed to cool off for a couple of years, but in 1981, 14-year old Peter Stogneff went missing. His body wouldn't be found for over a year, and during that time, 18-year old Mark Langley would go missing after an argument with his friends next to the Torrens River. A little over a week later, Langley's body would pop up, having been drugged and having the same sexual wounds as Alan Barnes and Neil Muir.

A few months later, a farmer who was burning away the dead crops on his vast acres of land stumbled upon the charred remains of Peter Stogneff. Police weren't able to find any evidence from his remains, but they did find the same type of saw wounds that had been used to mutilate Neil Muir's body, so they linked him to the same killer, as well.

Then, in 1983, fifteen-year-old Richard Kelvin was abducted in just a block or so away from his home, in North Adelaide. Richard was the son of Channel 9 News anchor Rob Kelvin, and his disappearance gave the investigation the highest profile imaginable.

The search to find Richard Kelvin ended just shy of two months later, when geologists stumbled upon his body in the Mount Crawford Forest. He had been held for at least a month by his abductor, and had the same horrifying sexual wounds as the other victims. And just like Alan Barnes and Mark Langley, he had been drugged by a variety of chemical agents, the most noteworthy of which was Mandrax, a prescription drug.

When police began to look at who had been prescribed Mandrax in the past, a familiar name popped up: Bevan Spencer von Einem. He had been implicated in three of the four abductions thus far, and with this link, police were able to take a further look at von Einem and his associates.


Police began to dig in further to investigate von Einem, and the allegations regarding him. An anonymous caller - who would later become known to detectives - had called just two days after the murder of Alan Barnes, alleging that von Einem was responsible. When he'd been questioned about it, he'd admitted to being gay, and admitted to a prior relationship with Neil Muir, the second victim.

Then, apparently, after the discovery of the fourth victim Mark Langley's body, von Einem had been investigated again, when it cropped up that he may or may not have sexually assaulted two young men down by the Torrens River in the preceding weeks. When questioned about Langley, he denied any involvement, but admitted that he had been in the area on the night in-question, and had been both drinking and driving.

Now, police had a direct link between him and the crimes: a prescription to Mandrax, the sedative that had been used to drug at least two of the victims. Investigators were now not only linking him to the sexual assault of a teenage boy named George, but also the murders of Mark Langley and Richard Kelvin.

Police were now eager to question von Einem, doing so surprisingly. They questioned his whereabouts on the night of Richard Kelvin's disappearance, and he quickly responded with an alibi: that he'd been sick. Apparently, he'd contracted the flu in the early weeks of June, and had actually taken an entire week off of work to recover.

Of course, this wasn't much of an alibi at all, it just served as an admittance of having an excess of time to himself. He had a doctor's note, but the appointment had been a quick one, in which he was prescribed more drugs to sleep and recover.

During this same bout of questioning, he revealed to investigators that he had been prescribed Mandrax for his insomnia, which he also treated by driving around for countless hours during the night and drinking. He also spilled that he had been prescribed Rohypnol in the past - "roofies" for short.

Police inquired if he'd consent to a search of his property: not only his home, but both of his vehicles. He responded by telling the investigators that he no longer owned two cars, just the one. His other vehicle, a Ford Falcon, had been sold just a month beforehand, in June. This also happened to be roughly a week after Richard Kelvin's body had been dumped in the Mount Crawford Forest, and he had gone through the effort of repainting the trunk before selling it to a family friend. He had not repainted the entire car - just the trunk.

When police inquired about his connections to the victims, von Einem had quick answers that seemed prepared. In a prior interview, he had made a small quip about being held up by a man of either Italian or Greek heritage; and in this interview, he told a similar story about a different incident involving a man of Lebanese descent. He seemed to deflect questions by attacking minority groups, detectives thought. Then, when asked if he would ever commit an act such as murder, he responded by saying that it was "unethical," which detectives viewed as a very odd response to the free-form question.

Needless to say, investigators quickly realized that they had found their man. Now, they just needed to prove it.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

After the first victim, Alan Barnes, had disappeared, Adelaide police had received a phone call. This was back in 1979, before they would learn about the depths of this unknown killer's depravity. They still believed that Barnes had been killed by someone known to him, making the crime a personal one, and not the act of a sexual sadist.

The phone call, made by an anonymous caller two days after Alan Barnes' body had been found, alleged that the young man had been murdered by Bevan Spencer von Einem. Now with von Einem in their sights, Investigator O'Brian and his colleagues wanted to get back to that original caller, to find out all that they knew.

Surprisingly, they were able to track down the caller. I'll simply refer to him as Investigator O'Brian does in his nonfiction book about the case, as "Mr. B."

When police spoke to Mr. B, they were surprised by a number of things. First of all, he was a younger bisexual man, who was barely a shade over twenty years old. He claimed to have befriended Bevan Spencer von Einem in June of 1979, at around the same time that Alan Barnes disappeared.

In order to avoid being spotted speaking to police, Mr. B went through a series of hoops to meet up with Investigator O'Brian. But he did, and told the police more than they had bargained for.

Mr. B described, in detail, how he had befriended von Einem, and how the two had become partners-in-crime. Mr. B told investigators about the cooler von Einem had in the backseat of his car at all times, full of beer which he would then try to ply on young-looking men that were walking on the side of the road.

Apparently, the two were successful in many of their endeavors. They preyed upon young men that were hitchhiking, and they would play themselves up as party-goers on their way to a fun function. Mr. B told investigators about the drugs von Einem would encourage his passengers to take, which he described to them as "No Doz," but was actually drugs such as rohypnol or Mandrax.

In the first part of this story, I told you about a young man named George, who claimed to have been picked up by a stranger and taken to the home of a transgendered woman. Mr. B, who we can only assume knew nothing of George or his statement to police, informed police about Bevan von Einem's transgendered friend, named Pru Firman, who would host him and any guests in exchange for drugs.

Mr. B also told police about how von Einem's mother would leave for a relative's house every other weekend, allowing him free reign. And he also described how von Einem's old home had had a very particular driveway, allowing him to abduct young men and teenage boys from driveway to his bedroom without being seen by any neighbors.

Mr. B also claimed to have been present during several of these abductions, but insisted that he always left before things got sketchy. He described one incident in detail, about how von Einem had drugged a pair of boys and begun sexually assaulting one in a way that was reminiscent to how the four victims had been found, before he decided to get out of dodge.

Despite this hiccup in his testimony, alleging fact but avoiding any repercussion, this was a huge get for the investigators. Not only was Mr. B filling in the gaps in the investigation where they had nothing, he was connected von Einem to the actions of a serial predator operating in the area.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Police finally had all that they needed, to at the very least build a case against Bevan Spencer von Einem. They had eyewitness testimony, they had von Einem implicating himself in multiple statements, they had statements claiming that he was a sexual predator of sorts, and now it was time to find the physical evidence.

They arranged to search his home in the Fall of 1983. The search went off without a hitch. In fact, it went a little TOO well for detectives to believe it was real.

Police searched his home and his vehicles. Sure enough, in the back seat of his car was a cooler, just as Mr. B had stated.

Inside, things looked like a regular home. There was no apparent evidence of a crime scene; no blood spatter on the walls, or a torture chamber. But von Einem openly admitted to having the drug rohypnol in the bathroom's medicine cabinet, which he had apparently obtained for sleep reasons.
Inside von Einem's bedroom, he had a large harp, which he was apparently quite good at playing. This is random, but would become a part of von Einem's defense later on.

However, when police searched his bedroom, they discovered a "hidden ledge" on the inside of his closet. There, still in the bottles that they had come in, were the drugs valium, Mandrax, and Noctec.
When he had been asked about the drugs, he had claimed to have had Mandrax in the past, but allegedly ran out in the preceding months. He had remained ignorant of both Valium and Noctec, and trace amounts of all of these drugs were found in the blood stream of Richard Kelvin.

Police had long-believed that their killer - or killers - would have been a sort of high-intellect type, with the way that the bodies had been cleansed of evidence and meticulously abducted. However, von Einem appeared to be inept, a buffoon who had trouble simply covering his tracks. He had hid the evidence linking him to a high-profile murder case like a Scooby Doo villain would have.

On the night of that first search, Investigator O'Brian remembered circling by von Einem's home that evening. He remembers staying for a good amount of time, parked down the street, just sitting and watching. In von Einem's driveway was a car, which O'Brian would later discover belonged to a local businessman, whom I'll refer to as "Mr. R." Investigators would later go on to finger Mr. R as being an associate of von Einem's, and a potential suspect, but never had enough evidence to move forward.

However, on the night where von Einem was officially searched as a suspect in the murder of Richard Kelvin, this acquaintance was there until the very early hours providing some sort of counsel or support.

A short time after this, on November 3rd, police arrested Bevan Spencer von Einem for the murder of Richard Kelvin. They wanted to try and link the other three murders - four if you included Peter Stogneff - at a later date, but wanted to move forward with Kelvin's murder case now.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Over the next few months, as von Einem awaited trial, police began to tear his house upside down, looking for any forensic evidence that could link him to Kelvin or any of the other young men.
They took a good amount of hair fibers from his clothing and furniture to the labs, where it would take some time to test against the DNA of the victims.

In the meantime, as police began to dig around von Einem's life, they discovered a few odd things.
Many of his coworkers, who had worked with him for months or years, described him as being very tame. He was a pretty quiet guy, but he also had bouts of being odd. Sometimes, when someone asked him mundane small-talk questions, such as how his weekend had been, he would respond inappropriately in the guise of a joke, suggesting that he had murdered someone. Or, in one occasion, had been seen acting inappropriately with young men in front of a coworker.

von Einem's associates also had a little bit screwy with their personal lives. His acquaintance, who I referred to as Mr. R, owned a local two-story business. When police did a search of the building, they discovered that almost all business was done on the bottom floor; the top floor was reserved for management, and one of the closed doors revealed an empty room that contained just a mattress.
This man was also spotted by police scouring the local areas where gay men met up, and was seen hitting on younger-looking men whenever he could. He would apparently close his business almost every day at lunch to walk around some of the nearby hot-spots, and police found this to be very odd for a man that seemed so professional from the outside.

Mr. R also had a roommate, who was allegedly involved with these murders in some capacity. His name was Stephen George Woodards, and he was an Adelaide-area doctor who would be surrounded in claims of sexual assault for decades, until facing charges in 2011 for crimes he allegedly committed in 1981 and 1982.


Ties linked these three men - von Einem, Woodards, and Mr. R - to other alleged group-members, including Derrance Stevenson, a high-profile lawyer murdered by his teenage lover in 1979 - a case that made international news when his body was discovered in his own freezer - and Gino "Luigi" Gambardella, one of Stevenson's associates who fled Australia in 1980 after multiple allegations tied him to sexual assaults of young men in the Adelaide area.

This searches led to no conclusive evidence, unfortunately. However, this was showing police the circles that Bevan Spencer von Einem ran in: a group of older men that preyed upon younger men. If what they were doing wasn't illegal, it was definitely unethical, and bordered somewhere between the two at the very least.

However, when the forensics returned from von Einem's home, they discovered a clear link to prosecute their guy.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Up until this point in the story, von Einem had denied any wrongdoing. He had been spotted with Alan Barnes in the days before his murder, had admitted to not only knowing Neil Muir - but carrying on a sexual relationship with him, and had admitted to driving in the exact area Mark Langley was murdered at the exact time he was abducted. But he had claimed to have had nothing to do with the disappearance of Richard Kelvin.

However, forensics proved otherwise. The clothes that Richard Kelvin went missing and was later discovered in contained fibers that linked directly to von Einem's bedroom and clothing. They found fibers from one of his cardigans on Richard's clothing, as well as fibers from his bed and floor.

Now that he had supposedly been pinned, von Einem chose to change his statement. Of course, this was totally unrelated to this burgeoning evidence, as von Einem toiled in a local jail. But nonetheless, von Einem chose to admit that on the night of Richard Kelvin's disappearance, he HAD encountered the youth. In his amended statement, he said that he had been driving in the area to pick up some food, and was driving around Richard's neighborhood, looking for parking.

And then, this is where von Einem's story crosses over into disbelief. He claims that he had encountered Richard, who wanted to come along with him that evening willingly. He stated facts that the newspaper reports had: that Richard had been going through some issues at school, that sort of thing - and said that he had talked to Richard as a friend. This took place at von Einem's home, of course, where they simply talked and hugged and played von Einem's harp for a couple of hours, before von Einem dropped him off at a bus stop and gave him twenty bucks to get back home.

However, this goes against three points: the fact that Kelvin had not gone willingly with whoever picked him up, based on the testimony of multiple witnesses that heard screams and shouts, and that von Einem had apparently been sick and bedridden all week long. Also, the fibers that examiners had found on Richard Kelvin's clothing implied that they were recent additions to his clothing; and since he had been held for over five weeks, it would have had to have been closer in time related to his discovery than his initial disappearance. This meant that the fibers would NOT have been present if he had been at von Einem's in June, but rather if his clothes had been at von Einem's closer to Richard Kelvin's discovery in July.

Needless to say, police and prosecutors didn't believe von Einem's statement whatsoever. It was just further proof to them that he was no criminal genius, just a sicko trying to stay afloat as he began to drown.

Now, by his own statement, he was the last person to see Richard Kelvin alive. Prosecutors called for his trial immediately, and by the Fall of 1984, von Einem was pleading not guilty in the murder of Richard Kelvin.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The trial of Bevan Spencer von Einem took place in 1984, and was a relatively tame affair.

After leaning on circumstantial evidence in the trial against Dr. Peter Millhouse in 1980, the police and prosecution wanted to go with a more heavy-handed approach, linking von Einem with not only the drugs found in Richard Kelvin's system, but also the fibers linking Kelvin to von Einem's home, and von Einem's own sketchy alibi and excuses.

von Einem's defense was flimsy at best. He had already claimed to have taken Richard Kelvin back to his house on the night that he disappeared, but claimed to have been sick the entire week afterwards. Then, on the night that medical examiners believed that Richard Kelvin's body had been dumped, he claimed to have been at a family friend's birthday party, along with his mother.

von Einem also claimed that, in the conversations he had had with Richard Kelvin on the night he disappeared, that the young man was struggling with his bisexuality. His family vehemently denied this, stating that he was heterosexual and had a girlfriend. Furthermore, there was no proof of this being the truth other than von Einem's say-so.

On November 5th, 1984, the jury deliberated for seven-and-a-half hours, ultimately leaning in the direction of guilt. Bevan Spencer von Einem was found guilty of Richard Kelvin's murder, and sentenced to a punishment of life in Yatala Labour Prison.

One of the first guests that would visit von Einem in prison would be none other than Mr. R, the business owner that had been tied to von Einem's nefarious activities.

As he began his sentence, police looked forward. They were already chomping at the bit to try and pin him for any of the other murders, but were still absent the necessary proof.

Justice had been found for one victim, but the police still had four related unsolved murders. Sadly, over thirty years later, the same thing can still be said.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Over the next few years, things were relatively quiet on the investigative front. Police were trying to find a link between von Einem and the other murders, to at least extract some kind of information out of him or his associates.

All that they had was the circumstantial evidence of the drugs found in von Einem's possession, which was much more of a slam-dunk case in Richard Kelvin's case than any of the others. Kelvin had been held and tortured for weeks, meaning that almost all of the drugs found in his system had been found at Bevan Spencer von Einem's home. Meanwhile, Alan Barnes and Mark Langley showed trace amounts of some drugs, but not all. And unlike Richard Kelvin, there was no forensic or physical evidence linking von Einem to their disappearances.

As the years passed, and the four unsolved murders languished in cold case hell, people began to speculate about two questions. The first was: did Bevan Spencer von Einem commit the crimes? And if he did, did he do it alone?

Mr. R, one of von Einem's closest associates, visited him multiple times in prison. Police still suspected him as being one of their main suspects. He seemingly scoured the local gay hot-spots for young-looking men, in an daily repitition that seemed as well-rehearsed as any. The upstairs office, which contained only a mattress and kept private, still stumped investigators and left them wanting to charge him with anything.

But, unfortunately, there was nothing to connect him to the crimes other than his association with von Einem and his sketchy behavior. However, most surprising was that an anonymous caller would call in and suggest that Mr. R has something to do with the unsolved murders, which gave police extra ammunition to observe him for anything out-of-the-ordinary.

Police continued to use Mr. B as an informant, trying to use the information he had about von Einem and link it to any acquaintances or accomplices that may have been present. Unfortunately, in an effort to extradite himself from any of the crimes, police had no specifics to go on.

Mr. B would claim that he had seen Alan Barnes with von Einem before his death, but that was the same type of circumstantial evidence that police wanted to avoid.

In an effort to go even further than that, Mr. B would then claim that he had personally overheard a discussion between von Einem and Mr. R. Apparently, during this conversation, Mr. B alleged that von Einem expressed interest in making a "snuff film" of Alan Barnes. This would actually fit into what another anonymous caller had stated years beforehand, about there being a snuff film made of Alan Barnes, but was unfortunately impossible to prove.

Mr. B would also sensationally state that von Einem had confessed to having involvement in the abduction of the Beaumont Children in 1966 and the Adelaide Oval abductions of Kristy Gordon and Jeanne Ratcliffe in 1973. There was no proof of these statements, sadly, but Mr. B's statements regarding them seemed convincing to police at the time.

{Part Two of "The Beaumont Children" episode can be found here, which goes into detail about von Einem and the allegations of his involvement with the Beaumont Children disappearance}

Even as the months began to melt into years, police were happy to have Mr. B to fall back on, to learn more about von Einem's secrets. Unfortunately, they kept getting road-blocked by Mr. B's unreliable instances, when he would lead police down the dark avenue of von Einem's crimes, but remove himself entirely and escape all responsibility. It was a survival mechanism, of course, but it made police wary of trusting anything he said.

That was further proven when the sister of Mr. B was contacted by police, and gave conflicting testimony. She stated that Mr. B had told her of an occasion where he had participated in the abduction and murder of a young man, which resulted in him throwing a body off of a bridge. To investigators, this meant that Mr. B might have had more involvement in the murder of Alan Barnes than originally thought, but after almost a decade since the crime was committed, was a dead end.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In 1988, police created a reward for information. $250,000, if someone was able to bring forth information that led to any resolution regarding the murders of Alan Barnes, Neil Muir, Peter Stogneff, or Mark Langley.

This renewed interest led to a revival in cries for justice, and police began working on a case against von Einem for the murders of Alan Barnes and Mark Langley. Those two, at least, had been found with drugs in their system, tentatively tying them to the murder of Richard Kelvin.

In 1989, the reward for information leading to an arrest was then doubled, and was now $500,000.
In 1990, von Einem was preparing to stand trial for these two additional crimes, police figuring that if they pinned two more murders to von Einem, it would make it easier to convict him for the separate murders of Neil Muir and Peter Stogneff. Unfortunately, before the case could even go to trial, the prosecution began to fall apart under the weight of Mr. B's testimony.

It was too sensational, too unrealistic, to stand up to scrutiny. And the fact that his own sister was testifying against him, stating that he was the type to make up stories to get himself out of a pickle, put police on edge. If they messed up this trial against von Einem, they would not be able to try him again, even if new evidence came to light in the future.

So, swallowing their pride, the prosecution pulled the case, hoping for more evidence to be unearthed in the future.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Over the years, the story of these murders would become a bit of an urban legend. Not only in Australia, but around the world.

When one police officer was interviewed regarding the case, he made the quip of "breaking up the happy family," in regards to an alleged conspiracy involving von Einem and other suspects. This would go on to be how the case was referred to: "the Family Murders," a collection of crimes committed by gay men in Adelaide that conspired to rape, torture, and murder young men.
And, you have to admit, the urban legend had some legs.

It's easy to point out a conspiracy theory and find flaws with it, but it's also harder to figure out how a buffoon like Bevan Spencer von Einem could escape justice if he was the sole perpetrator of the acts. He wasn't particularly smart - he worked as a middling accountant for a mid-end supply company - and lived at home with his mother. His idea of "hiding evidence" was to put it on the inside ledge of his closet, where police were able to easily find. And that's not even including his alibis, which shifted based on what he thought the police knew.

He wasn't some genius criminal. Police didn't think that he was smart enough to commit the crimes and get away with it - especially since the other related crimes showed signs of medical how-to.
Neil Muir's body was mutilated beyond recognition, but was done so by at least an amateur surgeon.

The same could be said of Mark Langley, whose corpse showed the signs of being operated on, with the surgical cut below his bellybutton. von Einem showed no signs of any medical expertise, and most likely would not have been able to perform such a surgery.

This leads to two possibilities: the first of which is that there was a criminal similar to von Einem operated in the area at around the same time. Which is possible. If anything, the last few years have shown us that a good amount of sickos were in the same area at the same time.

But the more likely possibility is that these deviants were somehow connected, perhaps working together or conspiring to achieve the same disgusting goals.

I personally lean towards the latter, not out of an effort to be a conspiracy nut. But rather, I just think that Bevan Spencer von Einem was too much of an idiot to commit all of the crimes on his own. I think he may have been a gopher of sorts for the group, and maybe was responsible for abducting the young men, but I don't believe he was the only person involved. At the very least, someone else performed the surgical procedure on Mark Langley.

Over the past few decades, police have agreed.

After the 1990 case against von Einem fell apart, the story started to flounder. Police had suspects, but no evidence to lob against them.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In 2008, the investigation into "the Family Murders" was finally re-opened, as police began to re-examine some of the long-forgotten evidence. This time, they were able to test it for DNA and forensics, but unfortunately, none of it came back with any matches.

The police had narrowed down the description of three suspects, who they allege may have worked with Bevan Spencer von Einem to commit the four unsolved murders.

The description of three suspects is as follows:

Suspect #1. An eastern suburbs businessman. Visited von Einem after his 1984 conviction. Interviewed in late 1983 and denied involvement in the Kelvin murder. Has also denied knowledge of the other murders, despite an informant telling police he saw him with von Einem and an unconscious Alan Barnes on the night Barnes was abducted in June 1979. Refused to answer questions when approached as part of the cold case review.

This is the suspect that I have been identifying as "Mr. R" throughout this episode. For legal reasons, I won't disclose this suspect's real name, but let me just say that you'll be able to find it easily enough with a Google search.

This is the suspect that police have had the most interest in, regarding the four unsolved murders. Apparently, police planned on charging him in the failed 1989 case against von Einem, before it fell apart in prosecution months later.

Suspect #2. A former Adelaide doctor who is well known in gay circles. Former lover of a well-known Adelaide lawyer. The pair used to pick up, drug and abuse young men. Known to have supplied drugs to von Einem and suspect #1, which were used to incapacitate hitch-hikers. Lives in Sydney and refused to answer questions as part of the cold case review.

This suspect was publicly outed in 2011, in regards to a different investigation. His name was Stephen George Woodards, and he appeared in court to defend himself against five charges of sexual assault against young men. The incidents he defended against ranged from January of 1982 to August of 1984.

Online theorists have speculated that the "well-known Adelaide lawyer" that Woodards had a love affair with was none other than Derrance Stevenson, the well-known gay lawyer who was murdered by his teenage lover, David Szach, in 1979.

I also don't find it a coincidence that Alan Barnes - the first Family victim - was abducted just thirteen days after the death of Stevenson. Rumors have long circulated that Stevenson had had an interest in Alan Barnes in the weeks before his death, and that all of these men ran in the same clique that included Bevan Spencer von Einem and Woodards himself.

I assume that the case against him failed, or the charges were dropped, as the last I could find of Woodards puts him in Bondi, a suburb of Sydney, Australia.

Suspect #3. A former male prostitute who is a close friend of von Einem and suspect #1. Police have considerable information that implicates him in picking up, drugging and sexually abusing hitch-hikers. Believed to have been with von Einem and suspect #1 when Kelvin was abducted, but has denied this. Now a bus driver in Brisbane, he fled Adelaide shortly after the cold case review was launched.

This is the suspect that I have identified as "Mr. B" throughout this episode. It's very possible that his name was leaked by a newspaper in 1989, but I don't want to get into a guessing game and risk legal action taken against myself.

This suspect is perhaps the trickiest of the lot. Police believe - now as they do then - that this individual had more information than he was letting on. He constantly implicated Bevan Spencer von Einem to places and dates, but had an excuse for himself, or would consistently state that he was involved with von Einem's abductions "up to a certain point."

However, these are just the three main suspects that police have identified throughout the years, and felt comfortable releasing the descriptions of to the public. It's possible, if not downright likely, that there were even more individuals involved who roam free today.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The case of the Family Murders has remained in the Australian zeitgeist for years now. And for good reason.

Criminologist Allan Perry has speculated that there may be dozens of victims, perhap up into the triple digits. After all, over 38,000 people go missing in Australia every single year, over 1,000 of which are never found. Who's to say that any of the open missing persons reports of young men from South Australia aren't related to these murdered men?

In 2014, the family members of Trevor Peters were going through his belongings in an area of eastern Adelaide known as Kensington. He had died a short time beforehand, and figured that it was about time.

Peters had been a gay man, and run around the same circles as Bevan Spencer von Einem and his associates in the late 1970s and early 1980s.

As his family members sorted through his belongings, they found a diary.

This diary, written by Peters decades before its discovery, went into detail about his relationship with von Einem, and the others that ran in their social circle. Trevor Peters' diary alleged that von Einem had discussed the abducton of Alan Barnes with his hairdresser, Denis St. Denis. And, according to Peters' diary, the pair had taken pictures of Barnes during the week he was missing.

Normally, this would just be a speculative lead: a man alleging that a convicted killer had a conversation, in public, with his hairdresser about an open crime.

But this diary had other, more important details. Such as the names of von Einem's associates, including the correct identities of the three main suspects, whose names police hadn't released. This diary also linked others to the same band of killers that Australia had called "The Family" for decades.

Another point of credibility in Trevor Peters' favor: he lived just a house away from the two transgendered women that Bevan Spencer von Einem allegedly used to lure young men to. The name of one has never been released, other than the fact that she was the sibling of an Olympic wrestler, but the other was publicly identified as Pru Firman, who died in 2010.

Many have theorized that one - or both - of these women were involved in the abduction and murder of the five victims. Perhaps one was the high-pitched voice that witnesses recall hearing during Richard Kelvin's abduction.

Trevor Peters' diary also alleged that von Einem, along with Denis St. Denis and perhaps another associate, rented an apartment in eastern Adelaide during the time period that the crimes occurred.

However, it has now been three years, and police seem to be no closer to solving this investigation than they were thirty years ago.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Trying to summarize this story is close to impossible for me, which is why I find this next section so hard to deal with.

Over the years, people have pointed fingers at a conspiracy of sexual offenders who perpetrated this attack. This is what we knowingly call "the Family." Others have pointed out the idea that this is ridiculous, and pointed out other such cases where these type of accusations proved fruitless.
However, I would just like to point out the following figures, who were active in the Adelaide area during the same time period that the Family Murders were taking place:

Mr. R, the #1 suspect behind Bevan Spencer von Einem, who they allege commited the Family Murders alongside the only convicted culprit.

Stephen George Woodards, the local doctor and surgeon who faced five charges of sexual assault against young men in 2011. He was revealed to be the investigation's #2 suspect, who also happened to live with Mr. R during this time period.

Mr. B, the witness that cooperated with police against von Einem, but was likely guilty of some of the same crimes. He openly admitted to being with von Einem on many occasions where he drugged young men, but police believe he was responsible for much more.

Pru Firman and her roommate, both transgender women who allegedly held "parties" in which they lured young men to their home in exchange for drugs.

Denis St. Denis, a longtime associate of von Einem's who was alleged to have been involved in the crimes.

Derrance Stevenson, a high-profile lawyer, who was murdered in 1979 by his teenage lover. He was a known associate of many of these figures, and a noted philanderer who enjoyed having sex with young men.


Gino Luigi Gambardella, a chiropractor who was close friends with both Stevenson and von Einem. He fled Australia in the early 1980s, after multiple allegations of sexual assault put him in the investigation's crosshairs.

Robert William Symonds, also known as "Mother Goose," a bookmaker accused of dozens of sexual assaults ranging from the 1970s through the 1990s. He stood trial in 2011 of multiple accounts of sexual assault, and was acquitted only because the evidence didn't stand up, almost thirty years later. He had found a way to escape charges the entire time.


Peter Liddy was Southern Australia's longest-tenured magistrate when he was convicted in 2001 of multiple sex crimes, including the sexual assaults of young men ranging as far back as 1969. Many of the assaults he committed couldn't even be tried because the statute of limitations had expired.


Richard Dutton Brown was another of South Australia's magistrates who was accused of multiple sexual assaults in the late 1970s and early 1980s. He was a gay man who prowled in the same hotspots as the other Family Murder suspects, and he died in 2010, before police could formulate an actual case against him.


Ric Marshall, the host of children's TV programs in the 1970s and 1980s, was the ringleader of a child sex ring that focused on young boys. He was convicted of multiple offenses in 2012, but because of his old age, was sentenced to only 25 years of house arrest.


Last but not least, Donald John Storen, a well-known boxing promoter and close friend of former-South Australian Premiere Don Dunstan. Storen left Australia to live in Indonesia, where he was later convicted of sexually assaulting and raping four boys in the mid-2000s.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If you think it's crazy that one or more of these many suspects may have communicated with another, when a clear link between several has already been established, think again. We already know that several of these accused - and in some cases, convicted - sexual predators were acquaintances. That is a fact. Who's to say more aren't involved?

I think believing that Bevan Spencer von Einem acted alone is the easy answer, to help us sleep better at night. The hard answer, and in my opinion, the more realistic one, is that he had an accomplice: maybe just one, but perhaps several. And for over thirty years now, all of them have escaped justice.

While the case file on Richard Kelvin may have been closed, the abductions, rapes, and murders of Alan Barnes, Neil Muir, Peter Stogneff, and Mark Langley remain unresolved.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If any of you would like to do any further reading on the story, you could head to the podcast website/blog, theunresolvedpodcast.com, to find sources I used when writing these episodes. The major source I used was the book "Young Blood," written by an Investigator behind the case, Bob O'Brian. It's chock-full of details, many of which I couldn't place in these episodes, so I'd encourage you to check it out.

If you head over the podcast's blog, you can also find links to the social media accounts, such as Facebook and Twitter. You can send emails to theunresolvedpodcast@gmail.com, no spaces, or you can call in and text at 831-200-3550.

You can support the podcast by heading to Patreon.com/unresolvedpod. I have a few tiers set up, and each get you access to some exclusive content; it's nothing game-breaking so far, just gets you early listens of each episode's "rough cut," any streams that Tyson or I set up, the ability to vote for future episodes, that kind of thing. I'm never going to paywall the podcast, but this is a good way to help financially support the podcast while also getting a little something in return. We're always trying to think up fun stuff to give back to the Patreon supporters, and rest assured we have even more fun stuff lined up in the near-future.

Speaking of, because of your Patreon donations, I've managed to buy a new piece of equipment that will allow me to conduct interviews. Let's just say that this may come in handy for a future episode...
So, I would like to thank all of the new Patreon supporters, who have helped make future episodes possible. These supporters are: Eliot, Mack, Jeanne, Francesca, Joy, Carlos, Joseph, Desirae, Corina, Samantha, John, Jay, Michael, Jarrett, Marty, Nathan and Anatoly. All of you: I can't thank you enough.

And, of course, before I wrap up this overly-long Academy Award outro, I'd be remiss if I didn't thank producer extraordinaire Tyson Nordgren, who pulls magic out of a hat every single episode. He produces the music you hear throughout each episode, and manages to make my rough recordings sound nearly-professional through computer magic. We all really owe him a lot for making this podcast sound as good as it does, so thank you yet again, Tyson.

That's it for this episode. Hope to be back sooner rather than later with another unresolved tale for you all. Until then, stay safe and goodbye.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sources

Wikipedia - The Family Murders

"Young Blood: The Story of the Family Murders" by Bob O'Brien

Adelaide Now - "Lost diary gives South Australia police new lead into Alan Barnes murder by The Family"

ABC Local News - Transcript of "Former SA magistrate sentenced to 25 years for child sex crimes"

The Australian - "How Mother Goose ducked pedophile net"

Adelaide Now - "Doctor with alleged links to The Family identified as Stephen George Woodards"

Adelaide Now - "Revealed: The double life of a magistrate who sought young men"

ABC News - "Former TV entertainer sentenced for sex offences"

The Sydney Morning Herald - "Aussie pedophile deported from Indonesia"

ABC News - "Mother Goose sex trial starts in Adelaide"

ABC News - "The body in the freezer"

ABC News - "Mother Goose acquitted of sex charges"

Adelaide Now - "Focus on three key suspects"

Adelaide Now - "Sex-case doctor Stephen George Woodards free to practise"

Adelaide Now - "'Mother Goose" claims he was set up by gay ex-prostitutes"